Best MLB Prop Bets: Top MLB Prop Bets for September 21st

Jesus Luzardo pitching against the Braves in Miami

Matt and Brian came through again! Dylan Cease and the Sox fell short of making it a perfect 3 for 3, but the bets went 2-1 last night with 2 plus money winners thanks to Aaron Judge’s 60th long ball and the top of the NL East taking care of business. We’re back at it tonight with a full slate of MLB action, there is day baseball but not bets for that today. If you want to bet along with us, sign up with any of the sportsbook welcome offers below. Onto our Top MLB Prop Bets for September 21st.

See Tuesday’s Top MLB Prop Bets

Top MLB Prop Bets for September 21st

Guardians vs White Sox 1st Half Under 4.0 (-130, Caesars)

This is definitely more juice than I like to lay, but I don’t really love the board today and I do really like this pitching matchup. The division race is essentially sewn up with the Guardians win last night, but Cleveland can really put the dagger in tonight. Tristan McKenzie throws against Lance Lynn. McKenzie is a terrible matchup for the White Sox. He’s a big strikeout pitcher who gets batters to chase, and the White Sox love to chase pitches out of the zone. Lance Lynn has been really good for the Sox yesterday, and I don’t see him being a letdown today. I think we see another early, low scoring battle before going to the bullpens.

Read more about Guardians vs White Sox

Your First Bet Is On Caesars Up To $1,250, plus get 1,000 Tier Credits and 1,000 Reward Credits®
Huge Bonus Offer
Why claim this offer
  • Generous welcome bonus
  • Offers same-game parlays
  • Mobile betting apps for iOS and Android

Xander Bogaerts Over 0.5 RBI (+145, DraftKings)

Bogaerts isn’t Boston’s best run producer, but he is their top hitter and has hit Chase Anderson well, going 5-for-10 off him during his career. Batting 3rd should allow Xander a few opportunities with guys on base tonight, and although I’d like him to struggle, (ya know, to help Aaron Judge keep the BA lead), I expect a good game from him. Getting these kind of odds on a 3-hole hitter to record an RBI is insane and the reason he’s a part of our Top MLB Prop Bets for September 21st.

DraftKings Deposit Bonus up to $1,000
Deposit Bonus!
Why claim this offer
  • Lots of promos and odds boosts.
  • User-friendly interface.
  • Wide range of sports and bet types.
  • Public and private pools for betting (sometimes free to enter).

Jesus Luzardo Under 7.5 Strikeouts (-125, BetMGM)

The lefty has been rocky in Miami and hasn’t exactly exhibited the stuff we saw when he first showed up in Oakland. His strikeout numbers have been more of a roller coaster than the stock market and he’s only gone over this prop ONCE over his last twelve starts. Jesus K’d 6 Cubs in early August and that was during a 1 hit outing over 7 innings. Personally, I’m not a fan of betting unders, but this prop screams “BET ME!”

Risk Free First Bet up to $1,000 with BetMGM
Sign Up Bonus
Why claim this offer
  • User-friendly interface and mobile apps
  • Good range of options for deposits
  • Offers same-game parlays

Aaron Judge HR (+215, FanDuel)

I said it yesterday and am sticking true to my word. The number is short but still longer than expected and better than anywhere else. The dude is not human this season and he’ll be a part of our Top MLB Prop Bets for September 21st and beyond.

FanDuel “No Sweat First Bet” Up To $1,000
Largest Sportsbook in the US
Why claim this offer
  • New users who sign up will get a “No Sweat” first bet up to $1,000!

This article is intended for entertainment purposes and adult users only. Call 1-800-GAMBLER if you have a gambling problem

Featured Image Credit: Eric Espada/Getty Images

WRITTEN BY

Matt Rooney

Matt comes from Chicago and has lived in the area his whole life. Graduated from and played football at Illinois Wesleyan University in Bloomington, IL while also serving as the director of student sports broadcasting. He writes for Betsperts as well as appears on several shows across the network.

Deals of the Day

See All